CarRentalList is built for exactly that: a U.S.-wide directory of independent exotic and luxury rental providers—no major chains or national franchises—so you can compare fleets and connect directly with the company that has the car you want.
CarRentalList currently tracks 187 independent rental companies and 2,136 exotic vehicles across the U.S.
Quick answer: the top independent exotic car rental companies (USA, 2026)
Below are CarRentalList's Top 10 independent exotic car rental companies in the U.S. based on a composite scoring model (fleet size + reviews/ratings + social presence + loyalty programs).
How CarRentalList ranks the "best" independent exotic rental companies
CarRentalList's rankings are built from a Composite Score (0–100) using:
Scoring Methodology
- Fleet Size (availability + selection) — up to 25 points
- Social Score (online presence) — up to 30 points
- Google Rating — up to 25 points
- Review Volume — up to 10 points
- Loyalty / membership programs — up to 10 points
This helps you avoid "flashy marketing only" and compare independent operators more objectively.
Last update shown on the ranking dataset: 2026-02-18.
Want the biggest selection? Top independent exotic companies by fleet size
If your priority is more inventory (more options + better availability), these are the largest fleets listed in CarRentalList's data:
| Rank | Company | Location | Fleet Size |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DS Luxury | Chicago | 146 vehicles |
| 2 | Veluxity | Capitol Hill | 117 vehicles |
| 3 | BluStreet Exotic Car Rentals | Newark | 76 vehicles |
| 4 | Buckhead Exotic Rentals | Buckhead | 66 vehicles |
| 5 | Supercar Exp | Boise | 62 vehicles |
| 6 | Axel Luxury | Chicago | 52 vehicles |
| 7 | MVP Miami | Miami | 47 vehicles |
| 8 | Miami Exotic Car Rental | Miami | 38 vehicles |
| 9 | Premier Luxury Club | Paradise Valley | 35 vehicles |
| 10 | G.M. Luxe | Miami | 33 vehicles |
Where are independent exotic rentals most common in the U.S.?
If you're flexible on location—or you're comparing destinations—CarRentalList's data shows the biggest hubs include:
CarRentalList also highlights top states and major city hubs directly on its U.S. directory experience (e.g., Florida, California, New York, Texas and cities like Miami, Orlando, Tampa, Fort Lauderdale, Los Angeles, Beverly Hills, San Diego, San Francisco, NYC, Manhattan, Long Island, Brooklyn, Houston, Dallas, Austin, San Antonio).
What does "independent exotic car rental company" mean?
On CarRentalList, "independent" means the provider is not a major rental chain or national franchise, and typically specializes in high-end inventory like Lamborghini, Ferrari, Rolls-Royce, McLaren, Bentley, and premium SUVs.
What you should expect to pay (typical U.S. exotic rental pricing)
Daily pricing varies heavily by city, season, and model, but CarRentalList's pricing research breaks the market into common tiers:
Common requirements (age, deposits, insurance)
Independent exotic rental companies usually have stricter rules than standard rentals. CarRentalList summarizes typical age requirements:
Drivers 21–24 may face higher deposits (example range: $2,000–$5,000) and tighter mileage policies.
How to find the best company for your trip using CarRentalList
Use this workflow to answer "who's top" for your city and car:
- Pick your location first (state → city) to avoid browsing fleets you can't actually access.
- Filter by make/model (e.g., Lamborghini, Ferrari, Rolls-Royce) to find who really has the inventory.
- Compare companies by fleet size and ranking signals, then click through to contact the provider directly.
- Confirm total cost (daily rate + mileage + deposit + insurance + delivery/pickup) directly with the company before you book.
Ready to find your exotic rental?
Browse 187 independent companies and 2,136 vehicles across the U.S.
Browse Directory